By John Wolfe, Staff Writer
At the risk of stating the obvious: the Web presents all kinds of new opportunities for networking and publicity. Musicians have known this for years now–just look at MySpace. If musicians can do it, why not authors and publishers?
To be frank, the book trade is at least a decade behind the music trade. Some traditional publishers and indie publishers are already looking for innovative ways to make use of the web for publicity and business purposes (our own blog is, we hope, an example of this) but many major publishers don’t seem to understand how useful the Internet can be.
To check out how effectively authors and publishers are using the full potential of the Internet, I decided to review the websites of the top six paperback trade fiction books on the current New York Times bestseller list:
1) “The Last Song” by Nicholas Sparks
2) “A Reliable Wife” by Robert Goodrich
3) “Little Bee” by Chris Cleave
4) “Dear John” by Nicholas Sparks
5) “The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo” by Stieg Larsson
6) “Shanghai Girls” by Lisa See
The Last Song
Design
This is quite honestly one of the most unappealing websites I have ever seen. The colors work together nicely and all, but honestly, they’re just boring. Pastel blues and greens definitely don’t stir excitement in my chest. Aside from what looks like the basic website template, there is nothing additional to this layout. I love simplicity. It’s a big deal for me if a website is too complicated or awkward to navigate effectively. But there is a big difference between simplicity and lifelessness.
Information
The main focus of the page is the synopsis. That’s nice, because why else would I want to go to a book website? Obviously I want to know what the book is about. Below the synopsis the website provides some awkwardly worded insignificant “Did You Know” facts about the book/movie production. Honestly, I’m not really interested in that. I’d rather read more about the book itself, or at least reviews.
The website does provide a review section, but it is stranded down in the left hand corner, and you have to change pages to read the entirety of the single review provided.
There are sections dedicated to Sparks’s comments about writing the book, his inspiration, FAQs, etc. However, these are once again displayed in boring, plain text format, with the same default layout.
Networking
The website does provide networking and Web 2.0 opportunities, which is almost a requirement if you’re looking for publicity on the Internet. It provides links for easy following via Facebook, Twitter, or Flickr, and provides a link to follow Sparks’s newsletter.
Conclusion
This website is more or less streamlined for information. However, the information presented on the main screen has been prioritized awkwardly. While too much razzle and dazzle can be a major turn off, too much plain text at one time is just as bad.
A Reliable Wife
Design
The website has an interesting, thin red frame, which gives it an almost dignified feel. The background image of a wintry forest is visually pleasing to me personally, since I’m so accustomed to it, but it also conveys the isolated and chilling feeling the book is supposed to provide.
There are several links at the top providing different informational pages, with the same layout. It’s convenient, easy to access, and understandable.
Information
This website provides, through the links at the top, more or less everything you’d want to know about the book. Right away on the home page it provides a synopsis and a video interview with the author, Robert Goodrich. This was well thought out. I don’t just want to read about what the author has to say about his book. I get a much more personal feel from hearing and seeing him talk about his book. To be honest, his commentary made the book a lot more appealing to me. I’m mildly interested already, just because of this interview.
What’s more, I’m provided an excerpt from the first chapter, as well as a page of reviews, book club style questions, and a text interview. Each bit of information is prioritized on its own page, and laid out nicely.
Networking
There is no “follow me” kind of option on the website. However, the main page lists websites and stores where the book can be purchased. However, networking is paramount when it comes to the web, and not having a “follow” option is really not utilizing the web to its full potential.
Conclusion
The website is informational, yet attractive at the same time. It’s not trying too hard to grab your attention. It’s constructed well, and isn’t at all confusing to navigate. It could be a little more colorful, and provide some more networking opportunities, but I feel as if the somewhat simplistic look of the page makes sense with the feel of the book, as according to what the author states. Overall, the website is well thought out, and provides an equal amount of interest and information.
The Little Bee
Design
The layout of this website is relatively simplistic–but compared to the website for “The Last Song,” it is infinitely more attractive. The template seems to be a traditional layout, maybe even a default web template. However, the colors are bright orange, and black. The contrast this creates is much more exciting than pastels. However, there is nothing particularly striking or exciting about the website. It’s constructed almost completely out of squares, which actually bores me, because once I notice it, I can’t stop. All I see are squares everywhere, and god knows I see enough squares throughout the day.
There are informational tabs at the top, with drop down menus, which seems to be pretty standard. The drop downs are nice, and give it a pretty modern feel.
Information
The book cover is displayed on the main page. However, there is no textual synopsis on the home page, which is a pretty big deal. There is a video interview with the author, Chris Cleaves, in which he provides the synopsis, and additional information about what inspired him. This was interesting. However, I still feel as if a textual synopsis is a selling point.
There are reader reviews at the bottom of the page, and a link to more reviews on the main page. There are several other links on the main page, along with the reviews link, which are not provided in the tabs at the top. There is one offering the first chapter, which is nice. It’s good to go for a test drive first. There are others pointing to the author’s inspiration, and suggestions on how to get involved with the issue the book presents.
However, these links floating about on the main page, unrelated to the tabs at the top, give the page unnecessary clutter. The viewer is being bombarded with orange links in all capital letters. It would be much better if they had reduced the lengths of the hyperlinks, or better yet, incorporated them into the tabs.
Networking
Way down at the bottom of the page, where no one ever looks, is a tiny little RSS feed button. Just in case you wanted to keep track of the book page. Well that’s helpful. I’d prefer not to have to hire a private detective to find the follow button for me. The reader reviews suggest some sort of community on the web page, but it’s not elaborated upon. There are tour dates provided on the tabs at the top of the page. Essentially, this page has a lot of work to do in the networking department.
Overall
The website looks all right, but after a while, the orange and the squares get to you. No one likes to be pounded in the face with all caps either, and it doesn’t help that they’re clutter. The page could use some reorganizing. Also, the Follow option really needs to be big, bold, and obvious. It’s one of the biggest publicity opportunities any author has on the web, and it absolutely needs to be used.
Dear John
Dear John should come next in this review, according to the top five list. However, the website is exactly the same as the website for “The Last Song.” There is absolutely nothing new here.
The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo
Design
The website is artfully simple, with a black on gray template, and a home page displaying the cover of the novel. There are tabs at the bottom for various other pages, such “praise”, “about Stieg Larsson,” and the like. The bar at the top is a constantly changing header that displays numerous positive reviews. The webpage gives the novel a somewhat mysterious feeling, due to its coloration and patterning. Everything on the website is easily accessible, simple, and well thought out.
Information
The website provides a synopsis, as well as reviews, and even a trailer for the upcoming movie. It also provides the first chapter for reading, which is definitely important. The tabs at the bottom for accessing the different information are simple and useful. Again, the website’s simplistic look is surprisingly helpful. All of the information I could want about the book is provided.
Networking
As far as I can tell, this book is already very well known. However, networking is still important. On the main display box of the website, in the lower right corner, are two banners. One reads “Tweet This Page.” That’s good use of networking in Web 2.0, however it’s a little hard to spot. Literally right on top of that banner is another one reading, “Friend Lisbeth on Facebook.” I thought that was a fascinating idea. Lisbeth is the protagonist of the book, and she has a Facebook. That’s not only good for networking, but just an interestingly new idea in general.
Overall
I actually enjoyed this website pretty well. It appeals to the simplicity that I love, without losing any aesthetic appeal. It also doesn’t lack any information, and it provides a fresh idea in networking. This website harnesses the publicity power of the web well, and I think it’s the best-designed site on the list.
Shanghai Girls
Design
The design of this website is actually fairly awkward. At first glance it looks like a big confusing jumble. It doesn’t have any outstanding or creative design, or any eye catching color patterns. It can’t quite be called simple either, because there is too much happening on just a single page. The design is lackluster, and generally uninteresting, if not even hectic.
Information
There is too much here. There are too many links on the side, and too many reviews scrolling vertically down the page.
On the side of the page are a plethora of links, starting off with a Beef Lo Mein recipe. I’m sure this has something to do with the book, so it’s probably a well thought out touch. There are two interview links below that, followed by a link to buy the book, and book club questions. A sample chapter is provided as well. There isn’t much that’s really new or interesting here. However, the website manages to provide more information than the website for “The Last Song”–as if that’s difficult.
Networking
There is little to now networking on this page. There is an option to e-mail Lisa See, or to join her mailing list. I found no twitter, Facebook, or RSS feed option on the actual novel page. If you navigate to the home page for Lisa See, there are Facebook and twitter options. However, it would probably be wise to place these on as many pages as possible.
Overall
This website could use a lot of work on its design. That is its major flaw: it is simply uninteresting. The information provided isn’t bad, or boring. Rather, it’s how the information is presented. To harness the power of web publicity, this website needs a pretty big aesthetic overhaul.
One Final Thought
I suppose I expected that the book sites that had been designed by authors rather than publishing houses—the book equivalent of indie music sites—would be more creative, given that the author has more freedom than the publisher.
As it turned out, though, the book website I enjoyed the most, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, was on a publishing-house site. I suppose it’s a sign that those with more corporate resources or backing can produce a flashier website, but even so, it’s disappointing to see the lack of imagination shown by authors creating their own sites.
Either way, it’s clear that web publicity for authors is still in its early growth, and we still have a fairly vast future of progress to look forward to before we can really see how publishers are going to make best use of the Web.